Talking Shop

 

 

 

  TOPIC

        An Interactive Magazine       

©Claire
Webmaster
Talking Shop Archive
relating to article 27.05.99

Genetically Modified

 
 

 

Thank you for the link Claudia. You answered my previous question when I read the following:

Organic standards ban the use of genetically-modified organisms (GMOs) in organic food. So if you buy organic, you can be sure that GM ingredients will not have been used in the production of the food at any stage.

Whew!

Kari ( .. who buys/eats organic and doesn't know what it means!)
ha ha, - Wednesday September 1st 1999 05:24:39


I'm reading the label right now on my little box of soy milk and it contains organic soy beans(*). When I follow the little star it takes me to another line which says *organically grown and processed in accordance with the California Organic Foods Act of 1990. So does that mean my beans are okay or not?
Kari
- Wednesday September 1st 1999 05:12:48


Follow the link on my name for more info about soya beans.

GM soya and maize are now approved as safe for use in Europe. Soya is currently one of the main sources of genetically-modified ingredients in food. It is estimated that 40 per cent of last year's US soya crop was genetically modified. Brazil and Argentina, the other main exporters of soya beans, are now growing GM varieties, too.
Claudia
- Wednesday September 1st 1999 04:51:53


It shouldn't Kari - Soya beans are one of the main things already in the food we eat that have been genetically modified, especially those from the US.
Claudia
- Tuesday August 31st 1999 01:25:17


My goodness, all this talk makes me very glad that I consume soy products instead of dairy!
Kari
Seattle, USA, - Monday August 30th 1999 11:56:12


Genetically altering cows to produce more nutritious milk? I thought milk was already supposed to be nutritious, although I've hated it for years. Strange that humans are the only mammals who seem to need milk after infancy. Brave New World. Genetically altering sheep, mice, cows. Only a matter of time before they get around to humans.
Georgia
Anaheim, Ca., - Wednesday August 25th 1999 05:53:22


Mentioned on the news the other night - trials are being carried out on genetically modifying cows to improve the nutritional content of milk. These trials/studies are in the early stages and GM milk isn't expected to be in the chilled cabient at your supermarket any time soon.
Claudia
- Wednesday August 25th 1999 02:30:18


UK Government has agreed to GM crop trials this week -- gggrrrhhh.

Claire
- Tuesday August 17th 1999 01:37:12


Oh yes Chris, we know!! :)))
Mireille Marchand
USA, - Monday August 9th 1999 11:17:21


Thank you Claudia - very informative. Claire I like your site.
Mireille Marchand , <mirmarch@hotmail.com>
USA, - Monday August 9th 1999 11:15:35


A previous topic of GMFs is in the news again, with 9 Ministers from the states of Australia and our own NZ Minister of Health meeting yesterday to discuss labelling issues for GMF foods.

Our website has the latest information - with 4 new fact sheets at the top of the page which I spent my weekend and most of Monday working on.

http://iwww.maf.govt.nz/MAFnet/index/gmfindex.html
http://iwww.maf.govt.nz/MAFnet/index/gmfindex.html">Claudia
- Tuesday August 3rd 1999 08:07:02


I don't know about "head patting". Probably genetically manipulated produce may not be the best thing to eat. Even organically grown produce is only as good as the soil and air quality. We are probably still eating DDT from the 1950s. I think that the GM veggies may be more of an issue in the UK. Do you think it is because of the "mad cow" situration a while back? Or the fact that Charles is an avid organic gardener? I would hate to see any of us become complacent to evil in the world. I do think that the Uk is generally safer than the US. More car thefts, maybe, but less guns. Just a personal opinion, but I would worry more about all of the people smoking cigarettes in England, France and Germany- Over here, smoking is the exception rather than the rule, and over there it seemed like half of the people we met were smokers. Mega health risk.
Donna
- Wednesday June 9th 1999 08:01:36


Yes, Claire. I knew that the farmers here had gone ahead with GM crops without asking my permission. The deal was supposed to be that the produce would be labelled in the markets so that consumers could decide whether to buy the stuff. I don't like the idea of GM crops; but, as I said, no one asked me. They just did it. It does scare me to think what the long-term effects may be. As far as I can tell, this battle was over before it began.
Andrea , <ezeitler@optonline.net>
LI,NY USA, - Wednesday June 9th 1999 03:55:23


There are those who can grow things, and those who cannot. I cannot. Unless you count dandelions and blackberry brambles, which appear to be dominating my yard. There was once an article in "Women's Day" magazine called "Ten House Plants You Can't Kill." I'd already killed eight of them.

There are those who can get through Tolkien, and those who cannot. In all four tries, I've become terminally bogged down somewhere in the middle of book 2. Much rather explore this Norse mythology sitting through "The Ring" instead.

And when you all have sorted out the risks and benefits of genetically engineered agriculture, would you let me know your conclusion? It's totally beyond me. I agree-- tomatoes don't taste like when I was a kid. But the apples are better. And there was no Ben & Jerry's then, either. Win some, lose some. I have a suspicion that the demise of the planet is more likely to be through politics than through agriculture.
Georgiana , <gellis@drizzle.com>
Seattle, - Wednesday June 9th 1999 03:29:33


I feel as if I have just been patted on the head " ... there .. there .. it's a bad old world out there but you will get used to it."

Rubbish,I wont get used to it whereever I live.

In all liklihood Americans have missed the opportunity to influence the US/Canadian states/government against GM products, they have gone ahead and allowed the proliferation of these products already in *your best interests*. Power of the business lobby.

So the first time this will be high enough in Americian priorities to worry about will be the first major crop failure? Or if the Europe market decides it won't purchase your GM crops?


Claire
- Wednesday June 9th 1999 12:28:29


I don't think it is indifference as much as prioritizing. The Columbine High school tragedy and the copycat episodes have got us all worried. Plus the whole Clinton thing, and Kosovo--who has the energy to worry about genetically altered veggies? Probably they have been doing it for years and none of us know about it-I have had some pretty sad tasting tomatoes-they taste like they were mutants. Probably in another ten years we can all rent ourselves out as nightlights, as we will probably be glowing in the dark. One of the nicest things about the UK is the commentaries on veggies, trolley rage, and the shock when something evil happens-unfortunately, the rest of us are getting used to it.
Donna
- Wednesday June 9th 1999 11:28:08


I'll add another link for your reading list!:

http://www.consumer.org.nz/tech/index.html

The Talking Technology Trust in New Zealand was developed to encourage discussion amongs the ordinary folk about science and technology, where it is headed and how it affects us all.

The 1996 Plant Biotechnology forum met again on 8 May, 1999 for Plant Biotechnology 2. Have a look at the draft conclusions and listen to the audio files of the conference.
Claudia
- Tuesday June 8th 1999 04:36:23


And its linked in the current Off Topic page .. thanks Lin
Claire
- Tuesday June 8th 1999 03:27:22


Lin has found a great article in her Canadian newspaper today,wondering why *you lot over the pond* seem to be in less of an panic over GM foods than us Europeans.

Accurately reflected here, if I may say, by the relative lack off feedback on the topic. On the other hand mention gardening... and you are off!

Claire
- Tuesday June 8th 1999 03:25:38


Enjoyed designing a garden using different textures, heights,colours in various seasons.Like using the garden and visiting other great gardens we have here, as Donna rightly says in the UK, but have absolutely no interest in the annual maintenance!

I'm about as much use in the garden as the kitchen. Kill so many houseplants, that cactus have been moved onto the kitchen windowsill as a last resort.

I hate cacti!


Claire
- Tuesday June 8th 1999 02:43:50


So Claire, do you garden? Lots of fantastic gardens in the UK-my husband's favorite is Great Dixter-very bold colors and textures. I like it too-Monet's garden is my favorite, although I loved all of them. Beth Chatto would be worth seeing, and all of you UK people can use the nurseries. I could too, but the paperwork is daunting, and the poor plants have to be root pruned, rinsed completely clear of any soil, and wrapped-don't know if anything but a bulb would survive the trip. I barely survive the trip, but if I could afford anything but economy, it would be less painful. I love David Austin roses too, but they had trouble with black spot, so I replaced them with rugosas. If you like roses, you might like rosa glauca-the most incredible leaf color!!!
Donna
- Tuesday June 8th 1999 12:26:59


Hey Deb...sounds like my kind of garden!!! Aren't perennials just the best!!!

A couple of my easy success stories are Purple Coneflower (Echinacia), Michelmas Daisy (great late bloomer), yarrow, columbine (early beauty). Those all do beautifully for me in addition to the winners you already have!

Btw...I'm totally in love with the David Austen English Roses I'm growing...they're gorgeous colors, fragrance to die for, and they repeat bloom. To top it off they're HARDY...winter here without the pampering my hybrid teas require...
Dana , <strom@methow.com>
- Monday June 7th 1999 09:36:24


I'm going to be trying a veggie garden for the first time this summer. Just doing the basics -- tomatoes, peppers, beans, etc. I've had flower gardens for several years now and am still amazed at how my perennials just take care of themselves and multiply every year! I have such things as delphiniums, daisies, coreopsis, phlox, heather, astilbe, foxgloves, candytuft, pinks, irises and lilies.
Deborah A. , <ceilidh@uniserve.com>
- Monday June 7th 1999 07:28:41


I share a house with my mom and dad. They know better than to let me near the plants, since I have the "black thumb": I've even killed the unkillable houseplant called mother-in-law's tongue. It's tough, but it didn't survive me. Maybe that was evil MA coming out . . .

Dad has the vegetable garden, though it's smaller this year; with his surgeries over the past several months, not as much time (and energy) for it. Still, we're looking at excellent tomatoes, green beans, purple-hull and blackeyed peas, and okra. Alas, no sweet corn this year, as Dad isn't up to the effort. 8-( For a wonderful type of sweet corn, try Silver Queen. Yummmmm!

Mom's the flower person. Roses and blue hydrangeas and hanging baskets of petunias, and tall iris in purple and gold and white, and gardenias that will take your breath away, they smell so sweet. We fill the house with them while they're in bloom.

Emus?! One of our neighbors over in the next block has emus--as I found out one evening coming home from work; I turned onto our street and there stood before me . . . an escaped emu. I thought I was hallucinating. Hmmmm--good fertilizer, you say? I have to get word to my dad. *grin* And maybe strike a deal with our neighbors!


Mary Anne , <maryanne_e@hotmail.com>
- Sunday June 6th 1999 04:38:16


My Mom doesn't understand why I bother to grow my own, but I believe it tastes better than what we buy at the supermarket (or even at the farm stands). This year I have zucchini, red bell peppers, yellow bell peppers, frying peppers, chinese eggplant, green beans, basil, parsley, and a few kinds of lettuce. The only thing I get more of than I can use is the parsley. So I dry that and have it all year.

Marigolds are planted in the vegetable garden to keep away pests and entice the pollinators. When necessary, I spray with Safer insecticidal soap.

Flower beds line the backyard. The irises are just done. The lillies will be next to bloom.

In addition to composting kitchen scraps, I mix the leaves from my oak trees together with grass clippings from my lawn. I also use dried grass clippings for mulch.

Pesticides and fertilizers are especially dangerous here because they get into the ground water (our drinking water).

Andrea , <ezeitler@optonline.net>
LI,NY USA, - Sunday June 6th 1999 02:27:20


You're right Donna...not especially cheaper but you know what's in it!!! I can peaches, pears, and tomatoes.

I envy you your long growing seasons and melons, Suz!!!! Only fruit here is killer raspberrier and apples! Eastern WA is the apple capital of the world!! (well, maybe NZ in there too Clods!)

I grow mostly easy keeper and use right away stuff...lettuce, spinach, corn, then carrots, onions, potatoes, also basil and make my own pesto to freeze.

Emus!!!!!! Here I thought my chickens were exotic!!! Lots of manure here...local horses and llamaas!!!
Dana , <strom@methow.com>
- Sunday June 6th 1999 07:56:15


I, too, have a flower garden, vegetable garden, as well as a jungle of house plants around the place. Sweet corn (my favorite!), tomatoes, cucumbers, squash, bell peppers, onions, cantaloupes, watermelons, blackberries, etc., etc. are being grown organically. Have a compost pile but also a LOT of emus, which supply most of the, um... fertilizer.

I love home grown fruits & vegetables, but the garden isn't as large as it used to be. There just seems to be less and less time for it every year.
Suzanne , <SuzanneK@bigfoot.com>
Hallettsville, TX, - Sunday June 6th 1999 07:16:43


Dana, I also am a fellow gardener, and have blueberries, red currants, gooseberries, kiwis, apples, and this summer, corn, tomatoes , onions and cucumbers. I also have a flower garden, and shovel one unit-7 yards of composted yard debris-called "compostuff" every spring. I use mostly organic-insecticidal soaps, row covers, and if something really has trouble, an organic fungicide. I find that it the soil is tended to, then the plants stay healthy. It really is not cost effective any more to "grow your own", but it is fun. Lots of farmers markets and roadside fruit and vegetable stands in this area. No problems with deer, but have killer slugs, and occasionally a racoon in the pond, besides the usual birds, cats, a tortoise, frogs and dragonflies.
Donna , <PDXDONNA@aol.com>
- Sunday June 6th 1999 01:08:54


So, here's my question....do many of you grow your own food?

I live in a very rural area and most people here grow pretty decent sized gardens and preserve food. We also have a huge Farmer's Market every Saturday in town with several certified organic farmers in attendance. I am therefore spoiled by having lots of great, nonmodified food at least in the summer months. In winter I buy my greens and salad stuff at the grocery store like everyone else. Organic is available even in this very small place because of a fair section of our population base being interested in natural foods.

anyway...what do you grow? What do you use for soil supplements? Kids around here know what it means to take out the compost bucket!! Or are any of you avid flower gardeners like me?

I'll admit to using chemicals on my roses only...I grow lots of them and they are kept separate from all my other plantings. Pesticides not required as we live in a very dry climate...just chemical food!

OK, that's enough...let's talk gardens!
Dana , <strom@methow.com>
- Saturday June 5th 1999 09:39:07


Does somebody Royal and famous visit this site .. probably not!But the Prince of Wales has pitched back in to the debate today in the Times. Lots of links on the Off Topic *Tomato* page now.
Claire
- Wednesday June 2nd 1999 02:43:43


"Our vegetable love should grow
Vaster than empires, and more slow . . ."

-------Andrew Marvell
MA
Ear-to-ear literary *grin* . . ., - Monday May 31st 1999 02:56:43


The possibilities are frightening, this is quote from the NZ MAF site on ethical considerations.

"For example when eating a vegetable will a vegetarian be concerned to learn that their broccoli contains DNA copied from a pig gene? If it were to contain copies of a human gene does this mean that the person eating it is a cannibal? "

Gives whole new meaning to the phrase *cauliflower ear*!
Claire
- Monday May 31st 1999 02:15:13


Lots of information on this subject on my work website. I'm just trying to work out if I'm allowed to comment! (they have all these rules for public servants - not even allowed to criticise the government!) ;^D Click the link on my name to take you to the site, and then go to the bottom lefthand corner IN NEWS and click on GMF.
Claudia
- Monday May 31st 1999 01:08:23


This topic brought to mind a piece entitled "Science Has Spoiled My Supper," by Philip Wylie. In this stinging little article he discusses how the appeal of food has been lessened in favour of preserving it, giving it greater "shippability," etc. His argument is that scientific research has given us food that packs better and lasts longer, but doesn't taste nearly so good. An excerpt: "[the food] is handsomely packaged; it is usually clean and pure; it is excellently preserved. The only trouble with it is this: year by year it grows less good to eat. It appeals increasingly to the eye. But who eats with his eyes? Almost everything used to taste better when I was a kid."

Though Wylie's attitude in this article is undeniably "curmudgeonly," I find myself thinking of it every time I am faced with grayish-pink tomatoes with all the flavour of cardboard--tomatoes that have supposedly been cultivated to be of uniform size so that they will pack better. They may have been easier to ship, but they make crummy spaghetti sauce! There are also strains of fruit that have been developed to be blight-resistant, or not so sensitive to variations in temperature, etc. Fine. But however big and beautiful the resulting peach, it must taste like a peach, or why bother? As Wylie puts it: " . . . if people don't eat onions because they taste like onions, what in the name of Luther Burbank do they eat them for?"

I'm a fan of science and scientific advancements, and I certainly wouldn't want to live without the daily blessings of scientific progress: penicillin, vaccines for various illnesses, possibilities for organ transplants, etc. But I'm also a fan of good food! Sorry if I've strayed from the point too much, but the topic just reminded me so much of Wylie, I couldn't resist bringing this up. Others?


Mary Anne
Think I'll go have a snack, now!, - Sunday May 30th 1999 05:11:16


When is a tomato not a tomato? Not my pathetic attempt to remember a joke - but the new Off Topic article!
Claire
- Thursday May 27th 1999 03:45:47